Skip to main content
43 min readmerchandise planningassortment planning

Merchandise Planning vs Assortment Planning

Merchandise planning sets the financial envelope for a season: sales, margin, inventory and receipts by category and month. Assortment planning decides which options, how many, how deep and at what price fill it. How the two connect, who owns each, and a knits category worked end to end.

Merchandise planning sets the financial envelope for a season, the planned sales, margin, inventory and receipts in dollars by department or category and month, and assortment planning decides which products fill that envelope: how many options, at what depth, at what price and in which size run, for which channels and clusters. The first is top-down dollars, planned from the business target down through the merchandise hierarchy; the second is bottom-up options and units, built from the product up; and a season is planned well when the two are reconciled into one plan of record before the buy is committed. The open-to-buy is the number that passes between them.

This guide is about the relationship, not about either discipline on its own. What is merchandise planning? defines the full stack as five layers, and what is assortment planning? defines the product layer for apparel. What neither does at length, and what a search for "merchandise and assortment planning" is asking, is set out how the money and the options relate as two disciplines: what each decides, where the hand-off is, who owns which, how one job becomes two as a brand grows, and what a season looks like when both are run in sequence. It covers the one-sentence answer and why the two are so often confused; a differences table; what each plan decides; the hand-off from the financial plan through the open-to-buy to the option plan and the buy; where line planning, demand planning, allocation, space planning and category management sit relative to both; the mechanism that decides whether one person does both jobs; a season walked end to end; a women's knits category worked through from the financial plan to the size run and back; how the envelope and the option plan differ in ten verticals; the failure modes; and how merchandise planning software and assortment planning software divide the work.

The one-sentence answer, and why the two get confused

The confusion is built into the vocabulary. Merchandise planning is used in two senses, and the sense is not always stated. In the wide sense it names the whole discipline: every plan a merchandising organisation makes between the budget and the shelf, from the merchandise financial plan down to the allocation. In that sense assortment planning is simply one layer inside merchandise planning, and the question "what is the difference?" has no interesting answer. In the narrow sense, the one a planner means when they say "I do merchandise planning and she does assortment", it names the financial layer alone: the sales, margin, inventory and receipt plan by category and month, and the open-to-buy that falls out of it. In that sense assortment planning is the layer directly below, and the difference is the whole subject of this guide.

The narrow sense is the useful one, because it is the one that matches how the work is actually divided. A planner working the envelope spends the week on dollars, stock-to-sales ratios, receipt flow and the variance between plan and actual. A buyer or merchandiser working the assortment spends the week on styles, colours, price points, depth and size runs. The two sit in the same meetings and read the same category, and they are answering different questions about it. The planner's question is how much the category can afford to receive and still hit the stock and margin plan. The buyer's question is which options, in what quantity, will sell through at that margin. Neither question can be answered properly without the other's answer, which is why the two are confused and also why they cannot be collapsed into one.

The glossary entry on merchandising planning uses the wide sense and lists the layers. The glossary entry on assortment planning defines the product layer. This guide uses the narrow sense throughout: merchandise planning means the financial envelope, assortment planning means the option plan inside it, and the open-to-buy is the hand-off between them.

Merchandise planning vs assortment planning: the differences

The table gives the comparison on the dimensions that matter in practice. Each row is expanded in the two sections that follow.

DimensionMerchandise planningAssortment planning
Question answeredHow much will this category sell, at what margin, holding how much stock, receiving how much each month?Which options will we carry, how many, how deep, at what price and size run, for which channels and clusters?
DirectionTop-down, from the business target through the hierarchyBottom-up, from the product and the customer up to the category total
GrainDepartment, category or class; total company or channelStyle and style-colour; SKU for the size run; channel and cluster
Unit of measureDollars at retail and at cost; stock-to-sales and turn as ratiosOptions, units per option, units per size; dollars only as a check back
Horizon and cadenceA year or more ahead; set before the season, reforecast monthly in seasonOne to two seasons ahead; set at line freeze and buy commit, revised at the in-season reads
OwnerMerchandise planner; finance reads it as a commitmentBuyer or merchandiser; design and product development feed it
Primary inputsLast year's actuals restated, the growth and margin target, the stock and turn target, the markdown plan, the retail calendarThe line plan, the open-to-buy, planned ticket and cost, sell-through history by attribute, size curves, vendor minimums, the cluster definition
Primary outputsSales, margin, reductions, opening and closing stock and receipts by period; the open-to-buyThe ranged option list with depth, price, size run, delivery and channel grid; a buy-ready unit plan
Software moduleMerchandise financial planning and open-to-buyAssortment and range planning; item and buy planning; size and pack
KPIs it is judged onSales to plan, gross margin, stock-to-sales, turn, receipt flow to plan, open-to-buy disciplineSell-through by option, full-price sell-through, size integrity, option productivity, markdown by option
What it cannot do aloneIt cannot say which products; it is a frame with nothing in itIt cannot say how much money there is; it is a list with no ceiling

Two rows carry most of the weight. The unit of measure is the real boundary: the envelope is in dollars and the option plan is in units, and the conversion between them, through the planned average ticket, is where most of the reconciliation effort goes. And the direction row explains why the two never agree on the first pass: a plan assembled downwards from a target and a plan assembled upwards from a product list are built from different information, and nothing in either method forces it to land on the other.

What merchandise planning decides: the envelope

The merchandise plan, in the narrow sense, is a set of linked financial lines for each node of the hierarchy and each period of the season. The lines are planned sales, planned reductions, planned gross margin, opening stock, closing stock and receipts, and they are linked by one identity: closing stock equals opening stock plus receipts minus sales minus reductions. Set any four of the five stock lines and the fifth is determined; planned gross margin sits alongside them, derived from the initial markup and the reductions rather than from the identity. In practice the planner sets sales from the target and the history, sets reductions from the markdown plan, sets closing stock from a stock-to-sales or weeks-of-supply target, inherits opening stock from the prior period, and lets receipts fall out.

That is the whole mechanism, and it is worth being plain about what it does and does not say. It says how many retail dollars of merchandise the category needs to receive in each month to hit the sales plan while holding the stock plan. It says, through the planned initial markup, how many cost dollars that is. It says, through the planned margin after reductions, what the category is expected to return. It does not say a single thing about which products those dollars will buy. A merchandise plan can be written for a category whose products have not been designed yet, and in a seasonal business it routinely is.

The merchandise financial plan

The merchandise financial plan is the top of the envelope: the sales, margin and inventory targets set first, before any product decision, well ahead of the selling season and at department or division level, then spread down the hierarchy to the categories a planner actually works. It is planned against the retail calendar, and phasing it by week or month is a discipline of its own, covered in how to phase a sales plan: the shape of last year's weeks restated for calendar shift, not the season total divided by the number of periods. The guide on merchandise financial planning covers the lines in detail. For this guide, the point is that the financial plan is the parent of the receipt plan, and the receipt plan is the parent of the open-to-buy.

The open-to-buy

The open-to-buy is the envelope expressed as money still free to commit. It takes planned sales, planned reductions and the target closing stock for a period, subtracts the opening stock and whatever is already on order to land in that period, and leaves the receipt dollars the buyer can still spend. The formula and its arithmetic are on their own page; what matters here is its role. The open-to-buy is the single number that crosses from merchandise planning to assortment planning. Everything above it is the planner's; everything that spends it is the buyer's. It is a ceiling, not a target, and a plan that treats it as a target to be filled has already lost the in-season flexibility that leaving some of it open would have bought.

Receipt flow and the stock plan

The envelope is not one season total but a month-by-month flow, and the flow is what the assortment has to be delivered against. A category planned to build stock into a peak month and run it down afterwards needs its receipts phased to land before the peak, which means the option plan's deliveries have to be dated to match. This is where the two plans first meet on a calendar rather than on a dollar figure, and where an option plan that is right in total and wrong in timing shows up: as a receipt month over plan, a stock-to-sales ratio out of range, and an open-to-buy that is exhausted in October with product still arriving in November.

What assortment planning decides: the option plan

The assortment plan, for the same category and season, is a list of options with a set of decisions attached to each. Which options, how many, how deep, at what price, in which size run, for which channels and clusters, landing when: that is the complete decision, and a plan that has made all of it for every option is buy-ready. The assortment planning template is one way to hold it; the structure is the same in a workbook or a planning system.

Option count

The option count is the number of distinct style-colours the category will carry, by class and price tier. It is the first decision because it is the one the envelope constrains most directly: receipt units divided by a workable depth gives the number of options the money can support, and a count above that number is a count that will be cut or starved. The option count is inherited from the line plan where one exists, rather than set in the assortment, a point taken up under line planning below, but the assortment is where the count meets the money and where it is adjusted if the two do not fit. The total line count formula multiplies the count through colours and sizes to the SKU count the plan will actually have to buy, allocate and manage.

Depth and the breadth-depth trade

Depth is units per option, and it is the number the envelope and the option count fight over. The style-colour depth formula is receipt units divided by option count, and the breadth vs depth entry sets out the trade: more options at less depth spreads the bet and starves the size run; fewer options at more depth concentrates the bet and protects size integrity. The trade is not decided in the abstract. It is decided per tier, because a core carryover option with a known sell-through can carry depth that a test option cannot, and it is decided against the size run, because depth below the point where the smallest size cell is viable is not depth at all.

Price and the planned ticket

Each option carries a planned ticket price and a planned cost, and the weighted average of the tickets across the plan is the number that converts the envelope's dollars into the assortment's units. If the option plan's weighted ticket drifts from the ticket the envelope assumed, the two plans disagree even when every other number is right. A plan that assumed a $70 average ticket and ranged options whose weighted ticket is $62 has bought more units than the stock plan allowed for the same dollars, or fewer dollars than the sales plan needs for the same units. The average unit retail formula is the realised version of this number; the planned ticket is its pre-season ancestor, and the two should be compared at the in-season reads.

Size run and pack

Below the option sits the size run: the sizes an option is offered in and the curve that splits its depth across them. The size curve decides how many units of each size the buy will carry, and it is the layer at which depth becomes real or illusory. An option planned at 300 units across eight sizes has a smallest size cell of around twenty units, and if that option is going to forty doors the smallest cell cannot be allocated meaningfully. The size run is an assortment decision, but it is the assortment decision most constrained by what sits below it, allocation, and most ignored by what sits above it, the envelope.

Channel and cluster grid

The last column of the option plan says where each option goes: which channels carry it, which store clusters, at what depth in each. This is the point at which assortment planning and allocation meet, and the grid is the assortment's hand-off to the allocator in the same way the open-to-buy is the planner's hand-off to the buyer. An option plan with no grid is a buy with no destination.

How the two connect

The connection is a sequence of hand-offs, each of which is a number one plan owes the next and the next is not free to contradict. The what is merchandise planning guide tabulates the hand-offs for the full five-layer stack. The version below is narrower and sharper: it traces the path from the financial plan to the committed buy and back, which is the path the merchandise-to-assortment relationship actually runs along.

StepFromToThe number that crossesWhat it fixes downstream
1Merchandise financial planReceipt planReceipts at retail by month, from the stock identityHow much merchandise lands each month
2Receipt planOpen-to-buyReceipts less what is already on orderHow much is still free to commit, by month
3Open-to-buyUnit ceilingOpen-to-buy at retail divided by planned ticketThe receipt units the assortment has to fit
4Unit ceiling and line planOption planUnits divided across options as depth, split by size runWhich options, how deep, in what sizes
5Option planBuy planUnits by option, size, delivery and vendor, at costThe purchase orders
6Option planOpen-to-buyThe option plan totalled at retail and at cost, compared with the open-to-buy by monthThe gap to close before commit; once committed, the buy relieves the open-to-buy month by month
7In-season actualsMerchandise financial planSales, sell-through and margin by categoryThe monthly reforecast, and the next season's envelope

Steps 1 to 3 are merchandise planning. Steps 4 and 5 are assortment planning. Step 6 is the check back, where the option plan is totalled in dollars and compared with the envelope it was meant to fit, and step 7 closes the loop. A process that runs steps 1 to 5 and never runs 6 has two plans. A process that never runs 7 builds next year's envelope from this year's envelope rather than from what happened.

The top-down and bottom-up reconciliation

The gap at step 6 is normal. The envelope was built downwards from a target and the option plan was built upwards from a product list, and the two were never going to land on the same number. The failure is not the gap; it is closing it late, or closing it by letting one side silently win. Aligning top-down and bottom-up plans sets out the reconciliation process, from setting the top-down targets first through building bottom-up by category to locking the resolved plan, and the levers for closing an over-plan: cutting options, cutting depth, retiming deliveries, or re-planning the envelope when its assumptions were wrong. This guide does not re-argue it. The point to carry across is that the reconciliation is a merchandising judgement, not a spreadsheet function, and what the plan has to supply is the gap, in both dollars and units, before the buy is committed.

Where line planning sits

Line planning sits between the envelope and the assortment, and it is the layer most often mistaken for one or the other. The line plan takes the envelope's implied unit ceiling and decides how many options the season will offer, in which classes and price bands, before any of those options has been designed; the assortment then selects from the line that design produces, and sets depth and placement against each option selected. The line is always bigger than the assortment, because it is a plan of what could exist and the assortment is a plan of what will be bought. Line planning vs assortment planning covers the boundary and the hand-off failure in which the full line becomes the buy without a financial check. For this guide, line planning is the first place the envelope's dollars become a count of options, and the assortment is the second.

Where demand planning, allocation and space planning sit

Three other disciplines touch both plans and belong to neither.

Demand planning estimates what customers will buy, at item and location grain where there is history to estimate from, and feeds both plans: a sell-through assumption into the envelope's sales line and a rate-of-sale assumption into the assortment's depth. It does not decide what the business will own, which is the envelope's job, or which options to carry, which is the assortment's. The three-way boundary between demand, merchandise and supply planning is drawn in demand vs merchandise vs supply planning.

Allocation sits directly below the assortment. It takes the committed units by option and size and decides which doors and channels receive them and when, against the cluster grid the assortment set. The assortment owes allocation a grid and a size run that can be distributed; allocation owes the envelope the sell-through by cluster that drives the reforecast.

Space planning constrains both from the side. Fixture capacity caps the option count a store can present and the depth a store can hold on the floor, which feeds back into the assortment's option count and into the envelope's stock plan. Space planning vs merchandise planning covers where the two meet. And category management, in the sense retailers use it, is the envelope's close cousin on the strategic side, setting the role and the financial shape of a product group that assortment management then fills; category vs assortment management draws that line.

One job or two: what decides the split

In a small brand one person does both. They set the category's sales and receipt plan in one tab and range the options in the next, and the open-to-buy is a cell that one tab writes and the other reads. This is not a compromise; it is the right shape for the work at that scale, and the discipline is identical whether the person is one or two. What matters is that the envelope is set and written down before the options are chosen, so that the option plan is checked against a number that was not derived from it. The small-brand failure is not doing both jobs; it is doing them in the wrong order, ranging the options design produced, totalling them, and discovering what the season costs.

What splits the roles as a brand grows is not revenue and not headcount for its own sake. It is the mechanics of the option plan, and three multipliers decide when one person can no longer hold the money and the options in the same week.

Option count. A category of forty options can be ranged, depth-set and sized by the person who also owns its dollars. A category of four hundred cannot, because the product decisions alone consume the week, and the envelope stops being reforecast because nobody has time to open it. The option count is the first multiplier, and the total line count formula shows how fast it compounds through colours and sizes.

Door and cluster count. A single channel with one assortment needs one option plan. A fleet with several clusters, each carrying a different subset of the range at a different depth, needs an option plan with a grid, and the grid multiplies every depth decision by the number of clusters. The work of deciding which options go to which cluster is assortment work, and it grows with the cluster count whether or not the envelope grows at all.

Channel mix. A brand that sells through its own stores, its own site and wholesale accounts is running three assortments against three envelopes, with different margin structures, different delivery calendars and different depth logic. The planner's work roughly triples because the envelope is now three envelopes; the buyer's work more than triples because the option grid now has a channel dimension on top of the cluster dimension.

When those multipliers are small, one person does both jobs and the hand-off is a cell reference. When they are large, the jobs split along the dollars-to-units boundary, and the open-to-buy becomes a formal hand-off between a planner who owns it and a buyer who spends it. There is no revenue threshold at which this happens, and a brand should resist being told there is one. The mechanism is the multiplier, and the multiplier is visible in the plan itself: count the options, count the clusters, count the channels, and the shape of the team follows.

A season walked end to end

The sequence below is one workable calendar for a seasonal category, written in months before the first delivery. The dates are illustrative; the order is not. Every step either sets a number the next step needs or checks a number the previous step owed.

WhenMerchandise planning doesAssortment planning doesWhat crosses
12 to 10 months outSets the merchandise financial plan for the season at department and category level: sales, margin, reductions, stock targets, receipts by monthReads last season's option productivity, size integrity and full-price sell-through by attributeThe receipt plan and the implied unit ceiling at the planned ticket
10 to 8 months outConverts receipts into open-to-buy by month, net of carryover programmes already committedSets the line plan with design: option count by class and price band inside the unit ceilingThe option count and price architecture
8 to 6 months outHolds the envelope; answers "can the envelope flex?" when the line comes in overRanges the assortment from the line: selects options, sets depth, ticket, size run and the channel and cluster gridThe first-pass option plan totalled in dollars and units
6 to 5 months outReconciles: compares the option plan total with the open-to-buy, by monthCuts options, trims depth or retimes deliveries to land the plan; or makes the case for re-planning the envelopeOne plan of record, locked
5 to 3 months outRelieves the open-to-buy as commitments are placed; tracks committed versus open by monthConverts the locked assortment into the buy: units by option, size, vendor and delivery; places purchase ordersCommitted dollars by month
3 months out to first deliveryWatches receipt flow against plan as deliveries confirm; flags months running over or underChases late deliveries and resolves vendor minimums that moved a quantityReceipt variance by month
In seasonReforecasts the envelope monthly from actuals; re-opens or closes the open-to-buyReads sell-through by option at the early reads; chases winners into the open reserve, cuts or marks down losersSales and margin to plan; the next season's starting point

Two things in that table matter more than the dates. First, the reconciliation is a scheduled step with a month against it, not something that happens if there is time. Second, the in-season row is where the two plans are most often allowed to separate: the envelope keeps being reforecast while the assortment is treated as finished at commit, and the two drift apart until the end-of-season review discovers how far. The in-season chase covers what the assortment side does with the reserve the envelope kept open.

A women's knits category, worked end to end

The example below walks one category, women's knits, through a six-month autumn and winter season from the merchandise financial plan to the size run and back to the open-to-buy. Every number is illustrative and chosen for clean arithmetic; none is drawn from any brand's actuals. The purpose is to show where each number comes from and which plan owns it, so that the hand-off is visible in the figures rather than described in the abstract.

Step 1: the merchandise financial plan sets the envelope

The planner sets sales, planned reductions and a closing stock target for each month. Opening stock is inherited; receipts fall out of the identity. All figures are retail dollars.

MonthPlanned salesPlanned reductionsOpening stockReceiptsClosing stockStock-to-sales
August300,00020,000900,000500,0001,080,0003.0
September360,00030,0001,080,000510,0001,200,0003.0
October420,00040,0001,200,000610,0001,350,0002.9
November540,00060,0001,350,000450,0001,200,0002.5
December540,00090,0001,200,000150,000720,0002.2
January240,000120,000720,000240,000600,0003.0
Season2,400,000360,000900,000 opening2,460,000600,000 closing

Each row obeys closing stock equals opening stock plus receipts minus sales minus reductions: August is 900,000 plus 500,000 minus 300,000 minus 20,000, which is 1,080,000, and so on down the table. The season total checks the same way: 600,000 closing minus 900,000 opening plus 2,400,000 sales plus 360,000 reductions equals 2,460,000 of receipts. Stock-to-sales is opening stock divided by the month's sales, so October is 1,200,000 divided by 420,000, or 2.9, and the ratio is held tightest into the two peak months where the stock is turning fastest.

The margin line comes from the planned initial markup. The planner has set a 62 percent initial markup, so cost is 38 percent of ticket. The goods that produce 2,400,000 of sales were ticketed at 2,760,000, the sales plus the 360,000 of reductions taken to sell them, and cost 38 percent of that, or 1,048,800. Planned gross margin is 2,400,000 minus 1,048,800, which is 1,351,200, or 56.3 percent of sales; shrink and other adjustments are left out for clarity. Receipts at cost are 2,460,000 multiplied by 0.38, or 934,800. At this point the planner has an envelope and no products. Nothing in the table says what a knit is.

Step 2: the open-to-buy

Some of the season's receipts are already committed: the first re-orders on the core carryover programmes have already been placed, and 360,000 at retail is on order to land across the season; the rest of the carryover depth is bought with the new season in step 4. The season open-to-buy is planned sales plus closing stock plus planned reductions, minus opening stock, minus on order:

2,400,000 plus 600,000 plus 360,000 minus 900,000 minus 360,000 equals 2,100,000 at retail, which is the 2,460,000 of planned receipts less the 360,000 already on order. At 38 percent of ticket that is 798,000 at cost. That is the number the planner hands the buyer. It is a ceiling.

Step 3: dollars become units

The buyer converts the open-to-buy into a unit ceiling with the planned average ticket for the new receipts. The planned ticket is the weighted initial retail of the options the category expects to range, not the realised average unit retail after markdowns, which will be lower. The planner and buyer have agreed a planned ticket of 70 for women's knits.

2,100,000 divided by 70 equals 30,000 receipt units. The planned average unit cost at a 62 percent initial markup is 70 multiplied by 0.38, or 26.60, and 30,000 multiplied by 26.60 is 798,000, which matches the open-to-buy at cost. The two currencies agree.

Step 4: the option plan

The line plan has given women's knits three price tiers, and the buyer ranges the assortment inside the 30,000-unit ceiling. Depth is set per tier, because a core carryover option with three seasons of history can carry more than a statement piece with none.

TierOptionsPlanned ticketDepth per optionUnitsRetail dollarsUnit costCost dollars
Core carryover125590010,800594,00020.90225,720
Seasonal fashion247560014,4001,080,00028.50410,400
Statement8954503,600342,00036.10129,960
Total4470.00 weighted28,8002,016,00026.60 weighted766,080

Each tier's units are options multiplied by depth: 12 multiplied by 900 is 10,800; 24 multiplied by 600 is 14,400; 8 multiplied by 450 is 3,600; together 28,800. Retail dollars are units multiplied by ticket: 594,000, 1,080,000 and 342,000, together 2,016,000. The weighted ticket is 2,016,000 divided by 28,800, which is exactly 70.00, so the option plan has held the ticket the envelope assumed. Unit cost per tier is ticket multiplied by 0.38, and cost dollars are 225,720 plus 410,400 plus 129,960, which is 766,080, the same as 2,016,000 multiplied by 0.38. Average depth across the plan is 28,800 divided by 44, or roughly 655 units per option. The style-colour depth formula is that last division.

Step 5: the size run

Each option is cut to a size curve. For the seasonal fashion tier, planned at 600 units per option across six sizes:

SizeCurveUnits
XS8%48
S20%120
M28%168
L24%144
XL14%84
XXL6%36
Total100%600

The cells sum to 600. The number to look at is the smallest: 36 units of XXL. If this option is going to twenty doors, that is fewer than two units of XXL per door, and the allocation will either hold the size back for the site or ship it to a subset of doors. That is a depth decision disguised as a size decision, and it belongs in the assortment review, not in the allocation week. The full category at six sizes is 44 options multiplied by 6, or 264 SKUs, which is what the total line count formula returns and what the allocator will manage.

Step 6: the check back to the open-to-buy

The option plan totals 2,016,000 at retail against an open-to-buy of 2,100,000. The plan is under by 84,000 at retail, which is 4.0 percent of the open-to-buy, or 1,200 units at the 70 planned ticket, or 31,920 at cost. The buyer and planner can fill it with a forty-fifth option or hold it. Here they hold it as an in-season reserve, so that the first sell-through read in September can chase a winner into October and November deliveries rather than find the money already spent. Phasing the new buy and the reserve against the receipt plan by month:

MonthPlanned receiptsAlready on orderNew buyOpen reserve
August500,00060,000440,0000
September510,00060,000450,0000
October610,00060,000500,00050,000
November450,00070,000346,00034,000
December150,00030,000120,0000
January240,00080,000160,0000
Season2,460,000360,0002,016,00084,000

Every row sums across: October is 60,000 plus 500,000 plus 50,000, which is 610,000. The columns sum down to the season figures: 360,000 on order, 2,016,000 of new buy, 84,000 of reserve, together the 2,460,000 of planned receipts the envelope set in step 1. The reserve sits in October and November because a chase placed on a September read lands there. The loop is closed: the envelope set 2,460,000 of receipts without naming a product; the assortment named 44 options, 28,800 units and 264 SKUs; and the two agree, by month, to the dollar, with 84,000 deliberately left open.

What the example does not show, because it is a pre-season walk, is step 7: the September read that shows the statement tier selling faster than the core, the October reforecast that lifts the envelope's sales line and the reserve that funds the chase. That is the in-season half of the relationship, and it is where a plan built as two separate files comes apart.

How the envelope and the option plan differ by vertical

The two plans exist in every vertical, and the hand-off between them is the same open-to-buy divided by the same planned ticket. What changes is the grain the option plan has to carry and the constraints the envelope has to respect before it can be spent. The merchandise hierarchy by vertical guide sets out the hierarchy each vertical plans against; assortment planning by vertical and open-to-buy by vertical cover each plan's vertical variations on their own. The notes below are only about how the two relate.

Apparel

The envelope is planned by department, class and month on the retail calendar, with distinct spring-summer and autumn-winter seasons and a markdown plan that is a real line, not a residual. The option plan is style-colour by size, with a size curve per option and a tiering between carryover, seasonal and statement that sets depth. The hand-off is the planned ticket by class, and the thing that most often breaks it is a price architecture that drifts between line freeze and buy, so that the weighted ticket no longer matches the envelope's assumption. The example above is the apparel case.

Footwear

The option is a style-colour, but the unit the buy and the envelope have to agree on is the size run within a width fit, and a run can be twelve or more sizes before widths are counted. Depth that looks adequate per option is thin per size, and a size run that is cut short to save depth sells out of the centre and leaves the ends. The envelope has to carry the model year rather than a pure season, because a carryover last with a new colourway is a different commitment from a new last, and the option plan has to separate carryover from new so that the envelope can see how much of the receipt dollars is already decided.

Accessories and bags

Carryover dominates. A core bag or belt runs for years with a colour refresh, so the envelope's receipt plan is largely replenishment of continuing options and the open-to-buy for new options is smaller than the category's sales would suggest. The option plan has to distinguish continuing from new at the top, because the depth logic is different: continuing options are sized from rate of sale and weeks of supply, new options from a planned sell-through. The hand-off failure is an envelope that treats all receipts as one number and leaves the buyer to discover how little of it is actually open.

Home and furniture

The option carries a long lead time and arrives by container, so the envelope's receipt flow is lumpy by construction and the option plan has to be built in container-sized multiples rather than smooth monthly quantities. Container minimums and vendor minimums set a floor under depth per option that the envelope has to know about before it sets the option count: an envelope that implies forty options at a depth below the container minimum is an envelope that will be spent on twenty. Floor sets replace the apparel delivery drop as the calendar unit, and dealer prebooks, where the channel has them, commit a share of the receipt plan before the open-to-buy is calculated.

Outdoor

The outdoor option plan runs on a model year, with a single launch and a long tail, and the envelope has to be planned against that year rather than against two apparel seasons. Dealer prebook is the defining constraint: a large share of the season's receipts is committed at the prebook deadline, months before the consumer season, so the open-to-buy that reaches the assortment is what is left after prebook, and the option plan has to be ranged for prebook with the at-once reserve planned separately. Carryover across model years is high and the option plan has to show it.

Sporting goods

Seasonality is by sport, not by calendar season, and a category's envelope is several overlapping envelopes with different peaks. The option plan is ranged per sport and the open-to-buy has to be held per sport too, because a dollar freed in one is not a dollar available in another whose peak has passed. Prebook from team and institutional channels commits receipts early, and the hand-off between envelope and option plan has to be run per sport on each sport's calendar rather than once for the department.

Beauty

The option is a shade within a range, and the range is the unit the customer sees, so the option plan has to range whole shade runs and the envelope has to fund them whole. Shelf life and retailer date-code policy cap how deep any shade can be bought, which puts a ceiling on depth that the envelope has to respect; receipts that would be efficient by the dollar are wrong if the product dates before it sells, and the period-after-opening symbol on the pack is a consumer label for the opened product, not a buying constraint. Gondola resets, not seasons, are the calendar the two plans have to agree on, and the reset date is the delivery the option plan is built to.

Toys and games

The envelope is dominated by the gifting peak, with a large share of the year's sales landing in a few weeks and the receipt plan built to land stock ahead of them. The option plan has to range for that peak and for the licensed windows that open and close on dates the brand does not control. The hand-off is unforgiving in both directions: an option plan that lands late has missed the year, and an envelope that holds a stock-to-sales ratio appropriate for an even seller will under-stock the peak. Case-pack constraints set depth multiples that the envelope's unit ceiling has to be divisible by in practice.

Baby and juvenile

Registry demand gives the category a steadier core than most, and the option plan separates registry staples, which are replenished against rate of sale, from seasonal and gift items, which are bought once. The envelope has to carry both logics in one receipt plan: continuous replenishment receipts that are planned from weeks of supply, and seasonal receipts that are planned from the open-to-buy. Safety and compliance requirements lengthen the lead time on new options, which pushes the line plan earlier relative to the envelope than in apparel.

Jewelry and watches

The cost base moves with precious metal prices between plan and buy, so the planned initial markup the envelope assumed may not hold at commit, and the hand-off has to carry a cost assumption that is revisited rather than a fixed percentage. Model years and carryover are long, and the option plan separates continuing from new as sharply as accessories does. Depth is low and the value per unit is high, so the unit ceiling is small and each option decision moves the envelope visibly; the reconciliation at step 6 is run option by option rather than at tier level.

Common failure modes

Each of these is a sequencing failure. The arithmetic in both plans can be right; what goes wrong is the order the decisions are made in or the frequency with which they are checked.

The assortment is built before the envelope. Design produces a line, merchandising ranges it, the buyer sizes it, and the total is discovered when the buy is costed. The stack has been run backwards: the option count was an output rather than a constraint, and the only lever left at commit is depth, which starves the size run. The fix is procedural, not analytical: the receipt plan and the unit ceiling are set and written down before the first option is ranged.

The envelope ignores option minimums. The planner sets receipts from the stock plan without knowing the floor that vendor minimums, container minimums or case packs put under depth per option. The implied option count is then higher than the money can support at a viable depth, and the assortment is cut at commit by someone who did not set the envelope. Case packs and planned depth covers the pack version; the general fix is that the minimum arrives in the envelope conversation, not the buy.

Two hierarchies. The envelope is planned on the finance hierarchy and the option plan on the product hierarchy, and the two do not map. A category in one is two classes in the other, a class in one straddles two departments in the other, and the check back at step 6 cannot be done because there is no node at which the two plans describe the same thing. One hierarchy, with the envelope planned at a level the option plan rolls up to, is the condition for the whole relationship.

The reconciliation runs once a season. The envelope and the option plan are reconciled at commit and then left. The envelope is reforecast monthly from actuals; the option plan is treated as finished; and by the end of the season the two describe different businesses. The in-season reads should re-open the comparison: the realised ticket against the planned ticket, sell-through by option against the depth that was set, receipts landing against the month they were planned for.

The planned ticket is assumed, not planned. The envelope's receipt plan is converted to units at last year's realised average unit retail, which already carries last year's markdowns, rather than at the planned initial ticket of this year's options. The unit ceiling comes out high, the assortment is ranged to it, and the buy lands over the open-to-buy at cost. The ticket the envelope uses and the ticket the option plan is ranged to have to be the same number, agreed between planner and buyer.

How merchandise planning software and assortment planning software divide the work

The two software categories divide along the same boundary as the two plans, and the category guides define each in full. What is merchandise planning software? defines the wider category as seven planning modules and a shared data layer: merchandise financial planning, open-to-buy, assortment and range planning, item and buy planning, size and pack planning, allocation and replenishment, and in-season reforecast and markdown. What is assortment planning software? defines the module or point solution for the option layer: the option count by class and price tier, the depth behind each option, the channel and cluster grid, and the size and pack profile, planned inside an open-to-buy it reads from the financial layer.

Read against this guide, the financial planning and open-to-buy modules are the envelope, and the assortment, item and size modules are the option plan. A brand that buys a merchandise planning platform has both on one data model, and the check back at step 6 is a view rather than a reconciliation exercise. A brand that buys only an assortment planning tool still has an envelope; it lives in a workbook or a finance system, and the hand-off, the open-to-buy figure and the planned ticket, is keyed across the seam. Neither is wrong. The question to ask of any product is where the seam is and what crosses it: whether the open-to-buy the assortment is planned against is the live figure or a copy, and whether a depth change in the option plan reaches the envelope's receipt line without someone carrying it there. The questions to ask planning software vendors guide puts that as a data model question to be asked in a first conversation.

Where RetailNorthstar fits

RetailNorthstar's merchandising planning page describes merchandising planning as the connected workflow that takes a brand from financial budget through assortment decisions, buy commitments, and inventory allocation, all in one system, and lists open-to-buy budgets that update in real time as assortment and buy decisions are made, and assortment planning constrained by OTB, in which every assortment decision is checked against the OTB ceiling. Its OTB planning page draws the same boundary this guide draws: OTB planning establishes the financial guardrails for a buying period and is the financial control layer, it does not decide what to buy, only how much; assortment planning determines which specific styles, colors, and sizes to carry within the OTB budget, using OTB as its financial constraint. Its assortment planning page describes attribute-level planning by style, color, size and fabric with automatic rollup to department totals, and OTB-constrained assortment, in which assortment decisions automatically reconcile against the OTB budget in real time.

In the terms of this guide, that is the envelope and the option plan on one data model, with the open-to-buy as the live hand-off between them. The evaluation questions above apply to RetailNorthstar as they apply to any product in either category, and a brand should bring its own category, its own open-to-buy figure and its own planned ticket to any demonstration, this one included.

Related resources

See how RetailNorthstar holds the open-to-buy and the assortment on one data model — the envelope and the option plan reconciled in the same view rather than in separate files.

Start Free Trial →

No credit card. No commitments.

Common questions

What is the difference between merchandise planning and assortment planning?

Merchandise planning sets the financial envelope for a season: planned sales, margin, inventory and receipts in dollars, by department or category and by month. Assortment planning decides which products fill that envelope: how many options, at what depth, at what price and in which size run, for which channels and clusters. The first is denominated in dollars and planned top-down from the business target; the second is denominated in options and units and built bottom-up from the product. They are reconciled into one plan of record before the buy is committed.

Is assortment planning part of merchandise planning?

In the wide sense of the term, yes: merchandise planning as a discipline is a stack of plans that runs from the merchandise financial plan down to allocation, and the assortment plan is one layer of that stack. In the narrow sense, the one used when a planner contrasts the two, merchandise planning means the financial layer, the merchandise financial plan and the open-to-buy, and assortment planning means the product layer below it. When someone contrasts the two, they mean the narrow sense, and that is the sense this guide uses.

Which comes first, merchandise planning or assortment planning?

The envelope comes first and the option plan is built inside it, then the two are reconciled. Merchandise planning sets receipts by month, which the open-to-buy converts into a receipt budget. The planned average ticket turns that budget into a unit ceiling, and the assortment plan spends the units as options multiplied by depth multiplied by size run. Building the assortment first and totalling it afterwards runs the sequence backwards and produces an option plan that has to be cut at commit.

How does open-to-buy connect merchandise planning to assortment planning?

The open-to-buy is the hand-off number. It takes the merchandise financial plan's sales, planned reductions and target closing stock, subtracts opening stock and what is already on order, and leaves the receipt dollars still free to commit. Dividing those dollars by the planned average ticket gives the receipt units the assortment has to fit inside. In the worked example the open-to-buy is $2,100,000 at retail and the planned ticket is $70, so the receipt budget is 30,000 units.

Can one person do both merchandise planning and assortment planning?

Yes. In a small team the same person sets the envelope and ranges the options. The question is not headcount but whether the two decisions stay separate when one person makes both. The envelope should be set and written down before the options are chosen, so that the option plan can be checked against a number that was not derived from it. What forces the roles apart as a brand grows is the mechanics of the work: the option count, the number of doors and clusters, and the channel mix multiply the product decisions until one person cannot hold the money and the options in the same week.

What is the difference between a merchandise plan and an assortment plan?

A merchandise plan is a set of financial targets by period: sales, margin, planned reductions, opening and closing stock, receipts and the open-to-buy that falls out of them. An assortment plan is a list of options with a depth, a price, a size run, a delivery and a channel or cluster grid against each one, totalled back to the dollars the merchandise plan allowed. The merchandise plan can exist before any product does; the assortment plan cannot.

How do merchandise planning software and assortment planning software divide the work?

Merchandise planning software is the wider category and holds the financial plan, the open-to-buy, the assortment, the buy and the allocation as one connected plan. Assortment planning software is the module or point solution for the option layer: option count, depth, size and pack profile and the channel and cluster grid, planned inside an open-to-buy it reads from the financial layer. A brand that buys only the assortment tool still has a financial plan and an open-to-buy; they live somewhere else, and the reconciliation between the two lives wherever the seam is.

RetailNorthstar Editorial Team
RetailNorthstar ·

Share this guide with your team

Copy a link or a pre-written message for Slack, Teams, or email.

// Know where your operation stands

Apply this to your planning operation.

The free Apparel Planning Maturity Assessment benchmarks your operation and tells you exactly which gaps to fix first.

Take the assessment →

Apply these insights with RetailNorthstar.

See how modern apparel brands use RetailNorthstar to put this planning framework into practice.

No credit card. No commitments.

Connected merchandise planning — live in weeks, not quarters.